Bureaucrats, Comment administrators, editor, Interface administrators, Administrators (Semantic MediaWiki), Curators (Semantic MediaWiki), Suppressors, Administrators, Widget editors
11,019
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Publishing Modification Comments (Shaw-Barseghyan-Yan-2019) (view source)
Revision as of 19:47, 3 March 2023
, 19:47, 3 March 2023no edit summary
{{Theory
|Topic=Workflow - Publishing Modification Comments
|Theory Type=Normative
|Subject=
|Predicate=
|Title=Publishing Modification Comments
|Theory TypeAlternate Titles=|Title Formula=|Text Formula=Normative
|Formulation Text=The discussions concerning a suggested modification are to be published once a communal verdict is available. The discussions are to be published in the journal as special commentary articles co-authored by all participants of the discussion or in special edited collections.
|TopicObject=Workflow - Publishing Modification Comments
|Authors List=Karen Yan, Jamie Shaw, Hakob Barseghyan,
|Formulated Year=2019
|Formulation File=
|Description=In the scientonomic workflow, the discussions concerning suggested modifications should be published once a communal consensus is reached and the respective verdict is recorded in the encyclopedia. The discussions are to be published in the journal as special commentary articles co-authored by all participants of the discussion or in special edited collections. While it might be tempting to only publish those discussions that caused significant disagreement in the community, such an approach alternative solution may inadvertently incentivize dissent and disagreement for the sake of getting published. In contrast, by publishing ''all'' discussions, we incentivize all commenting without skewing the incentive towards disagreement.
|Resource=Shaw and Barseghyan (2019)
|Prehistory=
|History=The idea of publishing the comments was first suggested in the scientonomic context by [[Karen Yan]], on May 23, 2020 at [[Scientonomy Conference & Workshop 2019|the first scientonomy conference]].
|Page Status=Stub
|Editor Notes=
}}
{{Acceptance Record
|Community=Community:Scientonomy
|Accepted From Era=CE
|Accepted From Year=2023
|Accepted From Month=February
|Accepted From Day=25
|Accepted From Approximate=No
|Acceptance Indicators=The idea became accepted as a result of the acceptance of the [[Modification:Sciento-2019-0002|respective modification]].
|Still Accepted=Yes
|Accepted Until Era=
|Accepted Until Year=
|Accepted Until Month=
|Accepted Until Day=
|Accepted Until Approximate=No
|Rejection Indicators=
}}
