Workflow - Publishing Modification Comments

Should the discussions concerning a suggested modification be published? If so, when and how should they be published?

In some academic workflows, discussions generated by publications are published as commentary articles, co authored by the participants. This can be done for a variety of reasons, such as incentivizing commenting, increasing communal participation and inclusivity, etc. In other workflows, ensuing discussions are left unpublished. It is important for the scientonomic workflow to clearly articulate how and when, if at all, the discussions on suggested modifications should be published.

In the scientonomic context, this question was first formulated by Hakob Barseghyan and Jamie Shaw in 2019. The question is currently accepted as a legitimate topic for discussion by Scientonomy community. At the moment, the question has no accepted answer in Scientonomy.

Scientonomic History

Acceptance Record

Here is the complete acceptance record of this question (it includes all the instances when the question was accepted as a legitimate topic for discussion by a community):

Community	Accepted From	Acceptance Indicators	Still Accepted	Accepted Until	Rejection Indicators
Scientonomy	22 December 2019	The publication of Shaw and Barseghyan (2019) is and indication of the acceptance of the question.	Yes

All Theories

The following theories have attempted to answer this question:

Theory	Formulation	Formulated In
Publishing Modification Comments (Shaw-Barseghyan-2019)	The discussions concerning a suggested modification are to be published once a communal verdict is available. The discussions are to be published in the journal as special commentary articles co-authored by all participants of the discussion or in special edited collections.	2019

If an answer to this question is missing, please click here to add it.

Accepted Theories

According to our records, no theory on this topic has ever been accepted.

Suggested Modifications

Here is a list of modifications concerning this topic:

Modification	Community	Date Suggested	Summary	Verdict	Verdict Rationale	Date Assessed
Sciento-2019-0002	Scientonomy	22 December 2019	Accept that the discussions concerning a suggested modification are to be published once a communal verdict is available. The discussions are to be published in the journal as special commentary articles co-authored by all participants of the discussion or in special edited collections.	Open

Related Topics

This question is a subquestion of Scientonomic Workflow.